We offer a variety of Amish made Baked Goods.
All of our baked goods are made fresh every Wednesday, then delivered around 3 pm to our store. All of our baked goods are made in Apple Creek / Millersburg, Ohio. We can pre-order any item, all orders must be made by noon on the Monday prior to delivery.
We will only hold the orders for 24 hours after delivery.
We offer a variety of Amish made Baked Goods.
All of our baked goods are made fresh every Wednesday, then delivered around 3 pm to our store. All of our baked goods are made in Apple Creek / Millersburg, Ohio. We can pre-order any item, all orders must be made by noon on the Monday prior to delivery.
We will only hold the orders for 24 hours after delivery.
Pie Varieties Available for Order:
Pie Varieties Available for Order:
Cherry**
Cherry Crumb
Blueberry**
Red Raspberry
Blackberry
Razzleberry
Elderberry
Blackberry
Pecan
Strawberry
Grape
Mince
Apple*
Dutch Apple
Peach
Rhubarb
Rhubarb Crumb
Raisin
German Chocolate
Lemon Meringue
Coconut Cream
Banana Cream
Butterscotch Cream
Chocolate Peanut Butter Cream
Pumpkin
Custard
Triple Berry**
_____________________________
Regular 9" Pies
Mini Pies
& Sugar Free Pies**
*Available upon request*
Cookie Pack Varieties Available for Order:
Cookie Pack Varieties Available for Order:
Assorted
Buttermilk
Butterscotch Oatmeal
Chocolate Chip
Chocolate w/Vanilla
Chocolate w/Caramel
Chocolate w/Peanut Butter
Chocolate Crinkle
Chocolate Whoopie
Molasses
M&M Monster
Oatmeal Raisin
Orange
Peanut Butter Blossom
Peanut Butter Drizzle
Pin Wheel
Pumpkin Whoopie (Seasonal)
Pumpkin w/ Cream Cheese
Snickerdoodle
Strawberry Whoopie (Seasonal)
Snow Balls (Seasonal)
Sugar
Sugar Cut-Outs
Thumb Prints (Seasonal)
Gingerbread Men (Seasonal)
Fried Pies Varieties Available for Order:
Fried Pies Varieties Available for Order:
Apple
Cherry
Red Raspberry
Peach
Blackberry
Pumpkin (Seasonal)
Strawberry Rhubarb
Blueberry
Strawberry
Black Raspberry
Lemon
Chocolate
_____________________________
**Select fried pies can be ordered with cream cheese in them for no extra cost**
Miscellaneous Items:
Miscellaneous Items:
Two Pack Cookies:
Chocolate Chip
Monster
Pumpkin
Peanut Butter
Snickerdoodle
Choc. Combo
Cut-Outs
Single Whoopie Cookies:
Chocolate w/vanilla
Chocolate crinkle w/vanilla
Strawberry w/strawberry
Choc. Chip w/vanilla or PB
Oatmeal Raisin w/vanilla
PB w/PB or chocolate
Molasses w/vanilla
Pumpkin w/cream cheese
Snickerdoodle w/vanilla
Monster w/ vanilla or PB
Cake Batter w/Vanilla
Additional Items that can be ordered:
Additional Items that can be ordered:
Bread: White, Honey Whole, Wheat, Doughnut, Pan Rolls, & Apple Cinnamon.
Favorites: Pumpkin Bars (& w/nuts), Cinnamon Rolls, Pecan Rolls & Brownies
Angel Food Cakes: White, Chocolate, Lemon, Strawberry, & Maple Nut.